
The Memory Keeper’s Daughter
by Kim Edwards
Why did I read it?
This was one of those books I’ve just “heard about” and the premise sounded really interesting. I ordered it in my enrollment package for the Quality Paperback Book Club, and after zooming through “Baby Proof” last weekend I felt for something a bit heavier.
What’s it about?
The book starts in 1964, when young Norah is in labor with her first child on the night of a snowstorm. Due to the storm, David, her surgeon husband, is forced to deliver the baby with only the assistance of a nurse, Caroline. Those days, women were often unconscious during birth, and after delivering a health baby boy, David is surprised to see another baby coming – a girl. But when he see’s the girl he recognizes immediately that she “isn’t right,” she has Down Syndrome. Having grown up with a sister who died young due to a heart condition, and being in shock, David directs Caroline to bring the baby girl to a “home” and tells Norah that she died shortly after birth.
But Caroline is appalled by the state of the “home” and ends up taking the baby girl (named Phoebe) and raising her herself, in Pittsburgh. The rest of the book follows both Caroline and Phoebe’s lives, and the Henry’s (Norah, David, and their son, Paul) from that fateful day, through the day that Norah and Paul finally find out about Phoebe, meet her, and begin to form a relationship with her (hey, you knew it would happen.)
Did I like it?
Ya know, for having such an interesting premise, the book was unbelievably boring and slow-moving. I didn’t think the characters were very well-developed either, and some of them seemed particulary contrived. That, and the authors way of writing was really tedious and uninteresting to me. She was WAY too descriptive and tried too hard with constant metaphors and such. I have to say, I was sorely dissapointed in this book and wouldn’t be interested in reading anything by Kim Edwards in the future.
Rating:
D






